NETWORK
|
LEARN
|
LISTEN
|
LAUGH
|
READ
|
SHARE
|
BOO
|
EVENTS
Login | Join us (Login problems, click here)
home soul soil society about people contact contribute
Can wild fish be labeled organic?
Keywords:
Categories: Soil
Published on: Mar 27, 2009
Last updated on: Mar 27, 2009
Add to favourites
When we buy a pork chop labeled "organic" we can assume that the pig that produced it ate only organic food, roamed outdoors from time to time, and was left free of antibiotics. An organic tomato must flourish without conventional pesticides. An organic chicken cannot be fed antibiotics.  

But when it comes to deciding what makes a fish organic, it is rather baffling. How does one control the wild fish which swim in pristine waters? This is a major issue in organic aquaculture

It appears that we can be sure about the organicness of the farm-raised fish like the salmon.    

But there are problems here too.  Environmentalists argue that many farm-raised fish live in cramped nets in conditions that can pollute the water, and it is not right to call them organic.

Even among people who favor the designation of farmed fish as organic, there are huge disputes over which types of fish should be included.   The issue comes down largely to what a fish eats.

How to feed the fish an organic diet?  

Catfish and tilapia are primarily vegetarians and hence can be brought under the organic category. Salmon, on the other hand is carnivores and eat other fish. How to label that organic? According to current regulations, wild salmon would not be able to be labeled organic, yet farmed salmon that abided by organic bylaws could.  

Wild tuna, swordfish, and halibut are probably not going to qualify because they are rarely, if ever, farm raised.  

So when it comes to buying organic seafood, don’t just look at the labels. First find out where the fish swam before buying.
Share   |   Report as abuse   |  
Like it! (1)
Abhijit Banerjee, 55
Been in the business of mass communication and ...
Calcutta
India
9 post(s)  |  6 comment(s)
2 comment(s)
 
ian russell wrote at 12:11:23 PM on Mar 30, 2009
I can't see how wild food can be controlled - it seems a contradiction. to label something ''organic'' means a strict method of control has been used, tested and authorised, so labelling something like wild salmon as organic is ridiculous, nothing more than a scam. anyway, if you look at farmed salmon and wild salmon, it's almost like two different fish something that's also reflected in the taste. I would say the salmon is a noble fish and should not be farmed.
Report as abuse   |   Like it! (0)
Abhijit Banerjee wrote at 12:54:58 PM on Mar 30, 2009
Precisely this ambiguity is the reason why organic remains so elusive in aquaculture. The USDA seemed to have the same question as you -"If it is wild and free, how can it be agriculture?" Even no authentic figures seem to be available on the exact share of aquaculture in the organic food market.

People have so far simply gone wild as far as fishing is concerned. There are more stories of unsustainable practices that how fish farms have developed.
Report as abuse   |   Like it! (1)
Login to post comment(s)
copperstrings posts:   home   |   soul   |   soil   |   society   |   about   |   people   |   terms of use   |   contact   |   contribute     
the copper network:   CONNECT   |   LEARN   |   LISTEN   |   LAUGH   |   SHARE   |   BOO   |   EVENTS   |   NEWSLETTER
CopperStrings post is not responsible for content on external Web sites. © 2008 www.copperstrings.com. All rights reserved.